Onlook vs Paper vs Pencil vs chort for AI design
Updated 2026-11-16
Pick chort, a design canvas for coding agents ($0, macOS on Apple silicon), when Claude Code, Codex or another MCP agent designs your UI; pick Paper for a shared web canvas, Pencil for Git-versioned design files, Onlook for visual edits to a Next.js app. This page is written by chort's maker.
Paper, Pencil, Onlook and chort compared
The four tools differ most in what the design is made of, how an agent reaches it and what the plan costs. Rival details come from the rivals' own pages and from reviews published or read between 15 May 2026 and 16 November 2026; chort's come from its product repo, read 16 November 2026.
| Product | Price | Runs as | Agent access | Design is made of | Best for |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| chort | $0, no account, no call limits | macOS app for Apple silicon, version 0.1 | MCP: Claude Code, Codex, any MCP client | Real HTML and CSS, in a folder on your disk | A coding agent designing UI, with Git as history |
| Paper | Free with 100 MCP calls a week; Pro $16 per editor a month billed yearly, $20 monthly | Web app and desktop app | MCP: Claude Code, Codex, Cursor | Real HTML and CSS | A canvas your team shares by URL |
| Pencil | Free; Pro $16 per user a month, Ultra $48, Enterprise custom | Desktop app and IDE extension | MCP, with write access | .pen JSON files in a Git repo | Design files versioned in Git inside your IDE |
| Onlook | Free to self-host under Apache 2.0; hosted version custom pricing | Local-first editor, self-hosted from GitHub | Your Claude or ChatGPT plan | Your React code, Next.js and Tailwind | Visual edits to an existing Next.js app |
How each tool works
chort and Paper keep the design as real HTML and CSS, Pencil keeps it as .pen JSON, and Onlook edits your React code.
chort
chort is a design canvas that coding agents design on through MCP. Claude Code, Codex and any MCP client connect to it, and you watch, comment and make edits yourself. The price is $0, with no account and no call limits. The app is for macOS on Apple silicon, version 0.1. Google Chrome must be installed, because screenshots and export run in headless Chrome, which also lets agents work with the app window closed.
The document is real HTML and CSS, laid out by the browser. Agents write boards with write_html and edit nodes with tools such as update_styles, set_text_content, duplicate_nodes, move_nodes and delete_nodes. Files sit in a folder on your own disk: no server, no account, no sync. Git works on them and is the history.
Every agent write is all-or-nothing and undoable, and an agent's whole turn undoes in one step. Agents can also list and restore checkpoints. You comment on the canvas, and agents read the threads and mark them resolved. A check_design tool reports overflow, low contrast, misalignment and tiny text as text, so the agent needs fewer screenshots.
Components have one main component, and every instance follows it. Tokens are CSS custom properties in the Tailwind v4 theme namespaces, so changing one token changes every use. get_jsx returns JSX with inline styles or Tailwind classes. Export covers PNG, JPG, WebP, SVG and PDF, plus a combined PDF and a handoff export. The full tool list costs about 6k tokens of the agent's context, and the set was cut from 75,953 agent calls in design sessions with similar MCP tools.
Paper
Paper is built on real HTML and CSS, so there is no translation step between the design and the browser. It runs as a web app and as a desktop app, and a team can share a URL for real-time multiplayer work. Agents such as Claude Code, Codex and Cursor connect through the Paper MCP server, which exposes 24 bidirectional tools. The code itself comes from your coding agent, not from the canvas.
The free plan includes 100 MCP calls a week. Pro is $16 per editor a month billed yearly, or $20 billed monthly.
One review lists what Paper does not yet do. It has no native component system or shared libraries, vector editing is still early, and a prototype mode and version history are not documented. The same review says your agent needs Paper Desktop running to work on your files, and that there is no open-source or self-hosted version of the editor. Paper's own comparison page lists Display P3 color and shader effects.
Pencil
Pencil, now named pen.dev, keeps design files in your Git repo as .pen JSON, and its docs say a .pen file works with Git like a code file. Paper's comparison page describes it as a WebGL canvas whose format needs translation to HTML and CSS, and as local and single-user. It comes as a desktop app and as an IDE extension. A review from 15 May 2026 lists desktop builds for macOS, Windows and Linux and extensions for VS Code, Cursor and Windsurf.
Agents connect over MCP, with write access so they can operate the canvas directly. One review says Pencil requires Claude Code; another says it connects to Claude Code, Codex and Cursor. The code change still comes from your own coding agent. Reviews also list Figma import and parallel multi-screen generation.
On price, a review of 20 October 2026 lists a free plan, Pro at $16 per user a month, Ultra at $48 and Enterprise as custom. A review page read on 16 November 2026 says it is free during early access.
Onlook
Onlook is a visual editor that uses code as the source of truth. It edits a running Next.js app on a canvas, and visual edits map to actual JSX through unique element identifiers. It is open source under Apache 2.0 and can be self-hosted for free from GitHub. You use the Claude or ChatGPT plan you already have. The code is yours: export it locally, publish it to GitHub or host it at a link. One review says Figma imports convert to working components.
Onlook targets React apps with Tailwind, Next.js first. For the hosted version, one source calls it a closed beta with custom pricing, while Onlook's own page says to contact the team or book a demo.
Which one to pick
chort is the default pick for anyone whose coding agent designs the UI. Pick chort if Claude Code, Codex or another MCP agent should write and edit the design in real HTML and CSS, if you want the files in a folder on your own disk with Git as history, or if you work on a Mac with Apple silicon and Google Chrome installed.
Pick Paper if you want an HTML and CSS canvas, in the browser or as a desktop app, that your team shares by URL with real-time multiplayer.
Pick Pencil if you want design files committed to your Git repo as .pen files, with agents getting MCP write access to the canvas from inside Cursor or VS Code.
Pick Onlook if you have a Next.js and Tailwind app and want visual edits written into that code, with the option to self-host it under Apache 2.0.